Current:Home > StocksThe Supreme Court takes up major challenges to the power of federal regulators-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
The Supreme Court takes up major challenges to the power of federal regulators
View
Date:2024-12-23 19:37:01
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday is taking up challenges by commercial fishermen to a fee requirement that could achieve a long-sought goal of business and conservative interests: limiting a wide swath of government regulations.
Billions of dollars are potentially at stake in front of a court that, like the rest of the federal judiciary, was remade during Donald Trump’s presidency by conservative interests that were motivated as much by weakening the regulatory state as social issues including abortion.
Lawyers for the fishermen are asking the justices to overturn a 40-year-old decision that is among the most frequently cited high court cases in support of regulatory power, including on the environment, public health, workplace safety and consumer protections.
Lower courts used the decision known colloquially as Chevron to uphold a 2020 National Marine Fisheries Service rule that herring fishermen pay for government-mandated observers who track their fish intake.
The 1984 decision states that when laws aren’t crystal clear, federal agencies should be allowed to fill in the details as long as they come up with a reasonable interpretation. “Judges are not experts in the field, and are not part of either political branch of government,” Justice John Paul Stevens wrote for the court in 1984, explaining why they should play a limited role. The court ruled 6-0, with three justices recused.
But the current high court, with a 6-3 conservative majority that includes three appointees of Trump, has been increasingly skeptical of the powers of federal agencies. At least four justices — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh — have questioned the Chevron decision.
Opponents of the Chevron doctrine argue that judges apply it too often to rubber-stamp decisions made by government bureaucrats. Judges must exercise their own authority and judgment to say what the law is, the lawyers for the company that owns the Rhode Island based Relentless and Persistence fishing boats told the court.
They also say that agencies effectively act as judges in their own cases. “It is patently unfair for a court to defer to an agency’s interpretation in cases where the agency itself is a litigant, before that same court, in the actual case at hand,” the lawyers wrote.
Defending the rulings that upheld the fees, the Biden administration said that overturning the Chevron decision would produce a “convulsive shock” to the legal system.
“Chevron gives appropriate weight to the expertise, often of a scientific or technical nature, that federal agencies can bring to bear in interpreting federal statutes,” Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar wrote on behalf of the administration.
Environmental, health advocacy groups, civil rights organizations, organized labor and Democrats on the national and state level are urging the court to leave the Chevron decision in place.
Gun, e-cigarette, farm, timber and home-building groups are among the business groups supporting the fishermen. Conservative interests that also intervened in recent high court cases limiting regulation of air and water pollution are backing the fishermen as well.
The justices are hearing two cases on the same issue. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson is recused in one case, from New Jersey, because she took part in it at an earlier stage when she was an appeals court judge. The full court is participating in the case from Rhode Island, which the justices added to their docket several months later.
veryGood! (76728)
Related
- Republican David Schweikert wins reelection in affluent Arizona congressional district
- This fund has launched some of the biggest names in fashion. It’s marking 20 years
- Attorney Demand Letter Regarding Unauthorized Use and Infringement of [SUMMIT WEALTH Investment Education Foundation's Brand Name]
- SpaceX faces $633,000 fine from FAA over alleged launch violations: Musk plans to sue
- Man jailed after Tuskegee University shooting says he fired his gun, but denies shooting at anyone
- Bad weather cited in 2 fatal Nebraska plane crashes minutes apart
- Fed cuts interest rate half a point | The Excerpt
- In-person voting for the US presidential contest is about to start as Election Day closes in
- Police cruiser strikes and kills a bicyclist pulling a trailer in Vermont
- Detroit Red Wings, Moritz Seider agree to 7-year deal worth $8.55 million per season
Ranking
- California Gov. Gavin Newsom will spend part of week in DC as he tries to Trump-proof state policies
- Hotter summers are making high school football a fatal game for some players
- Fed cuts interest rate half a point | The Excerpt
- What is Cover 2 defense? Two-high coverages in the NFL, explained
- Knicks Player Ogugua Anunoby Nearly Crashes Into Anne Hathaway and Her Son During NBA Game
- In-person voting for the US presidential contest is about to start as Election Day closes in
- Attorney Demand Letter Regarding Unauthorized Use and Infringement of [SUMMIT WEALTH Investment Education Foundation's Brand Name]
- Brewers give 20-year-old Jackson Chourio stroller of non-alcoholic beer for clinch party
Recommendation
Northern Taurid meteor shower hits peak activity this week: When and where to watch
7 MLB superstars who can win their first World Series title in 2024
Elle King Addresses Relationship With Dad Rob Schneider Amid Viral Feud
Florida sheriff shames 2 more kids after school threats. Is it a good idea?
Avril Lavigne’s Ex Mod Sun Is Dating Love Is Blind Star Brittany Wisniewski, Debuts Romance With a Kiss
Anti-'woke' activists waged war on DEI. Civil rights groups are fighting back.
Shohei Ohtani becomes the first major league player with 50 homers, 50 stolen bases in a season
Takeaways from AP’s report on churches starting schools in voucher states